"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has."

Margaret Mead

Case report

Alternating Biplanar Fluoroscopy in Percutaneous Nephrostomy to Approach Stones in Patients With Horseshoe Kidney: An Institutional Experience


This case series aims to evaluate the use of alternating perpendicular biplanar fluoroscopy in percutaneous nephrostomies/percutaneous nephrolithotripsies (PCNs/PCNLs) to approach renal stones in patients with horseshoe kidneys. Between January 2012 and December 2019, PCNs/PCNLs were done for six patients with horseshoe kidneys having renal stones. Skin and renal calyceal entry points were determined by alternating perpendicular biplanar fluoroscopy using a portable C-arm machine in the conventional fluoroscopy unit. The site of renal access, postoperative complications, and residual stones was assessed.

The mean age of the patients was 36.8 years. The mean stone size was 6.1 cm (2.1-16.05cm). In five out of six (5/6; 83%) patients, there was one access site. Four patients had their access site through the upper calyx, and one patient had it through the lower calyx. The stone-free rate was four out of six (4/6; 66.6%). One patient had a mild drop in hemoglobin postoperatively. There were no major complications reported.

The implementation of alternating biplanar fluoroscopy was found safe and helpful in providing a better appreciation of renal anatomy and stone location in patients with horseshoe kidneys. This technique helps in approaching horseshoe kidney stones in PCN/PCNL without moving the patient or fluoroscopy machine, with a potential decrease in operation time and radiation exposure.


The horseshoe kidney represents a congenital renal fusion anomaly with an abnormal position and rotation of the horseshoe kidneys that complicate the management of stones in these kidneys. The current treatment modalities include shock wave lithotripsy (SWL), retrograde intrarenal surgery, and percutaneous nephrolithotripsy (PCNL) [1]. PCNL is indicated for the management of large (> 2 cm) stones or in failed SWL [2].

In this case series, we report our eight-year institutional experience in utilizing alternating biplanar fluoroscopy in percutaneous nephrostomies/percutaneous nephrolithotripsy (PCN/PCNL) for approaching renal stones in patients with horseshoe kidneys. With this technique's success and convenience, we recommend its implementation not only for horseshoe kidney stones but also as a simple technique for approaching normal obstructed kidneys.

Case Presentation

This case series was based on six patients who had horseshoe kidney stones, which were diagnosed in the emergency department or outpatient clinic and were referred to the interventional radiology suite in our referral center for PCN/PCNL between January 2012 to December 2019. Data obtained from the electronic system included age, gender, radiologic investigations and procedure, stone-related data (size of kidney, collecting system dilatation, stone number, and location), access site, and postprocedure complications (Table 1).

  Patient 1 Patient 2 Patient 3 Patient 4 Patient 5 Patient 6
Age 32 34 37 55 27 36
Gender male male male male male male
Stone size 2.1 cm 6.05 cm 16.04 cm 4.9 cm 2.9 cm 4.92 cm
Stone location Multiple stones in the pelvis, upper, mid, and lower calyces of the left kidney Multiple stones in the isthmus and lower calyces of the right kidney multiple stone aggregates in the pelvis, upper, mid, and lower calyces of the right kidney multiple stones in the pelvis and upper minor calyces of the right kidney multiple stones in the pelvis and lower collecting system of the left kidney multiple stones in the isthmus and pelvis and lower calyces of the right kidney
Number of accesses 1 1 2 1 1 1
Access place  The lower minor calyx The upper minor calyx The upper and lower minor calyces The right upper minor calyx The upper minor calyx The upper minor calyx
Operation time/ min (PCN+PCNL) 23+103 = 126 35+162 = 197 32+83 = 105 33+120 = 155 30+120 = 180 37+110 = 147
Residual stone Yes, one stone Yes, multiple fragments No No No No stone postoperatively; however, had a new 8 mm stone after 4 months
Residual stone size 2 mm 23.6 mm N/A N/A N/A 8 mm
complications Hemoglobin drop by one unit None None None None None
Indication of procedure Urosepsis with renal stone, and failed SWL Large stone with failed SWL. Large stones Large stones Large stones failed SWL

Inclusion criteria: patients with horseshoe kidney presenting with symptoms of obstructive uropathy and/or infection and found in a radiologic exam to have a stone > 2 cm or underwent SWL treatment and failed. Six patients who met the inclusion criteria underwent PCN/PCNL. The procedures involved a portable C-arm machine to provide lateral fluoroscopy whilst the conventional fluoroscopy unit provided the anteroposterior (AP) view, resulting in alternating perpendicular image planes.

While the patient was in the prone position, local anesthesia was used with mild general sedation. Nephrolithotomy was applied under general anesthesia. The collecting system was visualized by direct puncture with an 18-gauge trocar or Chiba needle and then a wire was passed into the collecting system. Then, the needle was removed, and a dilator was placed over the wire. Afterward, the contrast was injected into the collecting system.

The calyceal and skin entry points were determined based on the stone location, and configuration of the collecting system. The calyceal entry point (CEP) is usually the posterior lower minor calyx in cases of posterior nephrostomy. In nephrolithiasis, entry through the posterior minor calyx is preferred when there is a staghorn calculus, a renal pelvis stone, a stone in the posterior lower minor calyx, or a stone in the anterior or posterior upper calyx. However, If the stone lies in the posterior or anterior middle minor calyx or anterior lower minor calyx, the entry is preferred to be through the calyx containing the stone.

The fluoroscopy was first done in the lateral view (using the C-arm), showing contrast-filled minor calyces lying in dorsal and ventral rows. The patient was then fluoroscoped in the AP view. The minor calyces would lie in lateral and medial rows representing the anterior and posterior minor calyces, respectively. The posterior lower minor calyx is the most caudal calyx in the dorsal row in the lateral view and the medial calyx of the lower calyceal group in the anteroposterior view.

Then, the skin entry point was identified. On lateral fluoroscopy, a sterile metallic pointer was maneuvered to lie just dorsal to the calyceal entry point. On AP fluoroscopy, the pointer was moved caudally until the line of the proposed nephrostomy track is directed toward the longitudinal axis of the lower major calyx. This point should be below the 12th rib and just lateral to the outer border of the paraspinal muscle. The skin entry point was punctured with an 18-gauge needle, which was advanced 2-3 cm into the subcutaneous tissue, then gradually advanced under alternating perpendicular biplanar fluoroscopy guidance, with the following main considerations:

A: The proposed nephrostomy tract (PNT) should be directed towards the CEP at all times as seen in AP and lateral views in fluoroscopy until puncturing the CEP (Figure 1).

B: First, using the lateral view, if the PNT seems to be dorsal to the CEP, the operator should correct the needle direction by tilting the proximal end of the needle cranially until the needle direction is pointing towards the CEP. The opposite should be done if the needle track is directed caudally to the CEP on the lateral view (Figure 2, panels a-b). The operator should fix the position of the needle in the correct position, then proceed to Step C.

C: In the AP view, if the PNT direction is lateral to CEP, the proximal end of the needle should be tilted ventrally (laterally) to recorrect the needle tract (Figure 2, panel c).

The needle was then advanced 1-2 cm deeper, with the same observations done in steps A-C until the needle tip was seen projecting on the target in both AP and lateral views. Additional technical details were previously reviewed [3-4].

Once the calyx is punctured, the stylet of the needle should be withdrawn and followed by a free backflow of urine. The guidewire was then advanced through the cannula into the minor calyx, the major calyx, and on into the pelvis of the kidney. The catheter was then inserted over the guidewire in the case of nephrostomy. But in nephrolithotomy, the tract was dilated by telescopic metallic dilators, and a metallic sheath was inserted. Small stones (1.2 cm or less on radiography) were extracted whole under biplanar fluoroscopy while larger stones were removed in fragments under direct vision using a nephroscope or by a laser device.

The same technique was applied for stones in horseshoe kidneys with minimal modifications needed because the renal congenital anomaly and the location of the stone and the needle can be visualized in both perpendicular planes alternatively.


The mean age of the patients was 36.8 years (range 27-55 years). All patients were male. Four patients had a stone on the right side, and two patients had left-sided stones. Three patients underwent SWL previously which failed to clear the stone completely. two had a history of prior renal surgery. Most of the patients presented with a history of flank pain. One patient presented with a renal stone, and symptoms/signs of urosepsis. The individual characteristics of the patients are shown in Table 1. Stone size was measured by summing the diameter of the multiple stones found in a renal unit. The mean stone size was 6.1 cm (2.1-16.05 cm). In 5/6 (83%) patients, there was one access site. Four patients had their access site through the upper calyx, and one patient had it through the lower calyx. One patient (17%) had two access sites; through the upper and lower calyces. Figure 3 demonstrates the fluoroscopic guidance of accessing a horseshoe kidney through the lower calyx.

The stone-free rate was found to be 4/6 in our study (66.6%) (Figure 4).

No major complications were reported in the patients. One patient had mild hemoglobin drop but did not require transfusion. All patients had their nephrostomy tube removed within 48 hours postoperatively and discharged home, except one patient who had urosepsis preoperatively that required a longer hospitalized treatment. Patients were followed with abdominal X-rays for six months. One of the patients had a stone recurrence on X-ray. However, none of the patients, even those with residual stones, became symptomatic during follow-up.


With newer advancements in interventional radiology and urology, different minimally invasive treatment options became available to address stones in horseshoe kidneys. These options include SWL, PCN/PCNL, ureteroscopy, and retrograde intrarenal surgery. SWL treatment was recommended for stones less than 2 cm in the horseshoe kidney. On the other hand, a percutaneous approach to tackle the stone in the horseshoe kidney is advised if SWL fails or for bigger stones [3]. By reviewing the horseshoe kidneys' PCN/PCNL results in some previous studies, the success rate was considered if all stones are removed or if the residual stone was less than 4 mm, which collectively ranged between 50%-87.5% (Table 2) [4-9].

Study group Number of patients Average stone size Stone free rate Complications Comments
Suelozgen et al. [4]. 2015 6 1007 mm2 (375-1480), 50%, Hematocrit drop in 66%. None needed a transfusion. The average operation time was 117.1 min. (44-250 min)
Al-Otaibi et al. [9]. 1999 12  N/A 75% N/A More than one nephrostomy tract was needed in 5 patients.
Satav et al. [7]. 23 22.03 ± 10.33 mm 87.50% Postoperatively, two patients had a fever, which was treated conservatively The mean operation time was 67.22 ± 7.63 minutes. One patient with a staghorn stone needed open surgery.
El Ghoneimy et al. [6]. 21 renal units (17 patients N/A 85.7% Intraoperative calyceal neck injury in one case, causing minor bleeding. Major renal pelvis perforation in one case, and one case of postoperative urosepsis. The operative time ranged from 30 min to 160 min (mean 70 min).
Etemedian et al. [5]. 21 37.2 ± 16.6 mm 71.40%. Minor complications were reported in 3 (14.28%) patients; transfusion in one (4.76%), fever in one (4.76%), and ileus in one (4.76%) patient  
Darabi Mahboub et al. [8]. 9 N/A 66.7% Access secured in 8/9 patients. One patient needed open renal surgery Two patients underwent SWL for residual stones.

Our study shows a comparable stone-free rate of 66.6% with a desirable profile of minimal complications. 

In horseshoe kidneys, the ureter usually originates from the upper part of the pelvis, which increases the risk of ureteropelvic junction obstruction and difficult calculus passage. Accessing the kidney through the upper pole not only facilitates access to the upper pole calyces but helps in accessing the pelvis, the calyces of the lower pole, and the proximal ureter [8]. Most of the patients in our study had puncturing through the upper calyx, and all were successful from the first attempt. One patient had access through the lower calyx, and one had upper and lower calyces puncturing.

The use of fixed alternating perpendicular biplanar fluoroscopy for entering the kidney provided a helpful appreciation of abnormal renal anatomy and obstructing stones while obviating the need of tilting the patient or fluoroscopy machine. This might lead to less potential operation time and radiation exposure to both the operator and the patient. Also, the technique would be easier to learn for interventionists in training. However, due to the small patient population and paucity of related studies in the literature, further evidence-based recommendations need more investigation.

Common complications related to the PCNL procedure include fever, bleeding, urine leakage, and symptoms caused by residual stones [4]. In our study, one patient had a minimal drop in hemoglobin but did not require any transfusion. Vascular injury risk during horseshoe kidney access is not higher than normal kidney access since the vessels of the horseshoe kidney enter the hilum from the anteromedial site with the posterior rotation of the calyxes [4,10]. Complications like a renal or gastrointestinal injury can occur after PCN/PCNL [4,6,11]. Yet, no major complications occurred in our study.

We utilized two perpendicular planes of fluoroscopy imaging with images being displayed on two separate monitors. This allowed entering the skin below the level of pleural reflection and provided three-dimensional monitoring for the advancement of the puncturing needle toward the target entry point. Therefore, the risk of pneumothorax becomes less likely to occur [12].

There is less definite evidence regarding the algorithm of management of stones in the anomalous kidney in comparison to the normal kidney. Less invasive treatment options like extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy (SWL), and ureteroscopy (URS) were found safe and effective in horseshoe kidney patients with a stone <2 cm [13]. On the other hand, multiple studies found that PCL was considered safe and effective in removing calculi larger than 2 cm in horseshoe kidneys [8,14]. Yet, further recommendations and comparison with other treatment modalities require further research and evaluation.

The case series was limited by the small heterogeneous patient population and limited follow-up time. Due to the paucity of related studies in the literature, further evidence-based recommendations need more investigation.


The use of alternating perpendicular biplanar fluoroscopy provided a better appreciation of the abnormal anatomy and stone localization in horseshoe kidneys in PCN/PCNL. Our case series shows that the implementation of biplanar fluoroscopy in PCN/PCNL in horseshoe kidney stones provided a stone-free rate of 66.6% that is comparable with other similar studies in the literature and with a desirable profile of minimal complications. The success and safety of this technique also make it suitable for use in normal kidneys with obstructing stones.


  1. Yohannes P, Smith AD: The endourological management of complications associated with horseshoe kidney. J Urol. 2002, 168:5-8. 10.1016/S0022-5347(05)64819-7
  2. Eryildirim B, Kucuk EV, Atis G, et al.: Safety and efficacy of PNL vs RIRS in the management of stones located in horseshoe kidneys: a critical comparative evaluation. Arch Ital Urol Androl. 2018, 90:149-54. 10.4081/aiua.2018.3.149
  3. Al-Muzrakchi A: Portable C-arm fluoroscopy unit improvized simultaneous biplane fluoroscopy. A simple and useful technique in interventional radiology. J Intervent Radiol. 1994, 9:37-43.
  4. Suelozgen T, Isoglu CS, Turk H, Yoldas M, Ilbey OY, Zorlu F: Our percutaneous nephrolitotomy experience in patients with horseshoe kidney. Arch Ital Urol Androl. 2015, 87:144-6. 10.4081/aiua.2015.2.144
  5. Etemadian M, Maghsoudi R, Abdollahpour V, Amjadi M: Percutaneous nephrolithotomy in horseshoe kidney: our 5-year experience. Urol J. 2013, 10:856-60.
  6. El Ghoneimy MN, Kodera AS, Emran AM, Orban TZ, Shaban AM, El Gammal MM: Percutaneous nephrolithotomy in horseshoe kidneys: is rigid nephroscopy sufficient tool for complete clearance? A case series study. BMC Urol. 2009, 9:17. 10.1186/1471-2490-9-17
  7. Satav V, Sabale V, Pramanik P, Kanklia SP, Mhaske S: Percutaneous nephrolithotomy of horseshoe kidney: our institutional experience. Urol Ann. 2018, 10:258-62. 10.4103/UA.UA_152_17
  8. Darabi Mahboub MR, Zolfaghari M, Ahanian A: Percutaneous nephrolithotomy of kidney calculi in horseshoe kidney. Urol J. 2007, 254:147-50.
  9. Al-Otaibi K, Hosking DH: Percutaneous stone removal in horseshoe kidneys. J Urol. 1999, 162:674-7. 10.1097/00005392-199909010-00009
  10. Janetschek G, Kunzel KH: Percutaneous nephrolithotomy in horseshoe kidneys. Applied anatomy and clinical experience. Br J Urol. 1988, 62:117-22. 10.1111/j.1464-410x.1988.tb04288.x
  11. Shokeir AA, El-Nahas AR, Shoma AM, Eraky I, El-Kenawy M, Mokhtar A, El-Kappany H: Percutaneous nephrolithotomy in treatment of large stones within horseshoe kidneys. Urology. 2004, 64:426-9. 10.1016/j.urology.2004.04.018
  12. Muzrakchi AA, Szmigielski W, Omar AJ, Younes NM: Is the 10th and 11th intercostal space a safe approach for percutaneous nephrostomy and nephrolithotomy?. Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol. 2004, 27:503-6. 10.1007/s00270-004-0228-9
  13. Chen H, Chen G, Pan Y, Zhu Y, Xiong C, Chen H, Yang Z: No wound for stones <2 cm in horseshoe kidney: a systematic review of comparative studies. Urol Int. 2019, 103:249-55. 10.1159/000500328
  14. Vicentini FC, Mazzucchi E, Gökçe Mİ, et al.: Percutaneous nephrolithotomy in horseshoe kidneys: results of a multicentric study. J Endourol. 2021, 35:979-84. 10.1089/end.2020.0128

Case report

Alternating Biplanar Fluoroscopy in Percutaneous Nephrostomy to Approach Stones in Patients With Horseshoe Kidney: An Institutional Experience

Author Information

Ahmed Al Muzrakchi

Radiology, Hamad Medical Corporation, Doha, QAT

Loai J. A. Aker Corresponding Author

Radiology, Hamad Medical Corporation, Doha, QAT

Radiology, Hamad Medical Corporation, Doha, QAT

Ali Barah

Radiology, Hamad Medical Corporation, Doha, QAT

Radiology, Hamad Medical Corporation, Doha, QAT

Ala Alsherbini

Imaging Department, Royal Melbourne Hospital (Melbourne Health), Melbourne, AUS

Ahmed Omar

Radiology, Hamad Medical Corporation, Doha, QAT

Ethics Statement and Conflict of Interest Disclosures

Human subjects: Consent was obtained or waived by all participants in this study. Conflicts of interest: In compliance with the ICMJE uniform disclosure form, all authors declare the following: Payment/services info: All authors have declared that no financial support was received from any organization for the submitted work. Financial relationships: All authors have declared that they have no financial relationships at present or within the previous three years with any organizations that might have an interest in the submitted work. Other relationships: All authors have declared that there are no other relationships or activities that could appear to have influenced the submitted work.

Case report

Alternating Biplanar Fluoroscopy in Percutaneous Nephrostomy to Approach Stones in Patients With Horseshoe Kidney: An Institutional Experience

Figures etc.


Scholarly Impact Quotient™ (SIQ™) is our unique post-publication peer review rating process. Learn more here.